New State-Private Venture Seeks To Mine Global Warming

Carbon » Company would pump greenhouse gases below ground

By Tom Harvey

The Salt Lake Tribune


Salt Lake Tribune

Posted:02/24/2009 06:33:01 PM MST

 

Utah as host to a cluster of new coal-fired power plants is not exactly the vision for a new economy based on clean energy. But the first business venture spun out of the state's 3-year-old science and technology initiative might mean exactly that, with a twist.

The plants clustered in Carbon County would not emit carbon dioxide, the gas from burning fossil fuels that causes global warming. That's because the carbon dioxide would be captured and pumped underground where it would be kept permanently in a kind of global warming jail.

Officials from the state, the University of Utah and the Utah-based company Headwaters Inc. announced Tuesday the creation of the first joint venture to come out of the Utah Science Technology and Research Initiative. USTAR was begun in 2006 to bolster research at the university level that could then be spun out into business ventures, creating wealth and jobs for the state.

Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. along with university officials and Kirk Benson, CEO and chairman of Headwaters, announced formation of the joint venture called Headwaters Clean Carbon Services to develop and operate carbon dioxide sequestration projects and offer those services to coal-fired plants.

"What we've discussed … is the possibility of setting up a regional storage center, one site that would serve many power plants," said Brian McPherson, associate professor of civil and environmental engineering who was lured to the University of Utah from New Mexico by the USTAR program to pursue his research on carbon dioxide storage. "It could handle new power plants that are built but also the [existing] Carbon, Hunter and Huntington power plants, as an example."

But while the promise of burning coal, the most abundant current energy source in the United States, without spewing green house gases is comforting, it also is costly.

The capture and storage of carbon dioxide could add a minimum of $10 million a year to the cost of operating a typical coal-fired plant, said Benson. Given that, carbon storage will have to be paid for through a system for capping carbon emissions and then giving companies the ability to trade credits for parts of the cap they don't use, or through a carbon tax as the Obama administration has proposed.

"Without an incentive such as cap and trade or a carbon tax, [carbon dioxide storage] won't be funded," said Benson.

McPherson and researchers in his lab are studying three areas -- in Utah, New Mexico and Texas -- to test the mechanical aspects of pumping carbon dioxide underground and the geological effects of the gas itself. But McPherson believes the system will work right now.

"I'm very confident we can do it on a commercial basis but it would be premature to do it before we finish testing," he said.

Utah has the potential for storing 2 billion tons of carbon dioxide, or 50 years worth of capacity from the power plants operating in the state today, said McPherson.

The Union of Concerned Scientists, a group concerned with resolving environmental problems through science, says carbon sequestration is one potential option for reductions in carbon dioxide emissions.

"In no way, however, should geologic carbon sequestration be seen as a 'silver bullet' to reducing emissions, nor should it be researched and developed at the expense of other environmentally sound, technologically feasible, and economically affordable solutions to climate change," the group says.

The Utah officials said the site under consideration in Carbon County is on state school trust lands and could bring in additional funds for Utah schools, as well as hundreds of jobs at new plants.

Headwaters, with its offices in South Jordan, is a major supplier of fly ash that comes from burning coal and that is used to strengthen concrete. It also creates coal-based synthetic fuels.

Benson said his company brings to the joint venture the expertise in interacting with the coal power industry and the ability to manage large projects.

"We don't have to build the expertise," said Benson. "We have it."

Huntsman said the announcement on Tuesday was a celebration of the USTAR program "having arrived."

"I've always been a believer in the idea that a couple of very important industries are going to be formed out of our state that will revolutionize the world," Huntsman told a gathering of state, company officials and journalists. "And I think we're scratching the surface on one right here today."

tharvey@sltrib.com